Why Netanyahu Is Refusing to Quit Despite Trump and the Polls

Why Netanyahu Is Refusing to Quit Despite Trump and the Polls

Donald Trump thought Benjamin Netanyahu might be ready to throw in the towel. He was wrong. When Trump publicly mused to ABC News that the 76-year-old Israeli Prime Minister might choose to walk away after a bruising, multi-front war, he underestimated the survival instincts of Jerusalem's longest-serving leader. Within hours, Netanyahu's Likud party shut down the speculation with a short, sharp statement on X: "Prime Minister Netanyahu will run in the upcoming elections – and with God's help, he will win."

This isn't just a standard political pushback. It's the opening salvo of what promises to be the most volatile election in modern Israeli history. The vote must happen by October 27, 2026. For Netanyahu, it represents an all-or-nothing gamble to preserve his legacy, stay out of prison, and maintain his grip on power.


The Trump Comment That Forced Likud's Hand

Trump's offhand remarks to journalist Jonathan Karl carried a subtle undercurrent of dismissal. "I don't know, he's had an amazing career. Does he want to continue?" Trump said, noting that Netanyahu is a "wartime prime minister" and that the conflict would end shortly one way or the other.

Reading between the lines, Trump was softly signaling that maybe it's time for a fresh face in Jerusalem. It's no secret that the relationship between the two leaders has grown incredibly tense behind closed doors. Just last week, Trump publicly admitted he called Netanyahu "fu*** crazy" during a heated argument over military strategy. Reports also indicate that Washington warned Israel it would be left to fight its own battles if it kept launching unilateral strikes against Iran.

By questioning Netanyahu's desire to run, Trump accidentally gave the Prime Minister exactly what he needed: a reason to draw a hard line and reassert total control over his party. Likud members didn't hesitate. They know their political survival is entirely tied to the boss.


The Reality of the Numbers

If you look at the raw data, Netanyahu's decision to run seems almost delusional. The public mood in Israel is dark, exhausted, and overwhelmingly ready for change.

A fresh poll from the Israel Democracy Institute released on June 9, 2026, paints a devastating picture for the incumbent.

  • 61% of all Israelis believe Netanyahu should not run for re-election.
  • 57% of Jewish Israelis share that exact same sentiment.
  • 64% of center-right voters want him gone.

These aren't just left-wing protesters shouting outside his residence. This is a massive chunk of the center-right political base saying they've had enough. The public still holds him heavily responsible for the systemic intelligence and defense failures surrounding the October 7, 2023 attacks. Combine that with a sluggish economy, ongoing legal corruption trials, and recent health scares—including the removal of a localized prostate tumor earlier this year—and any normal politician would have retired to a beach house long ago.

But Netanyahu isn't a normal politician. He understands the math of the Knesset better than anyone else in the country.


Why the Anti-Netanyahu Bloc is Stuck

Here's the dirty secret of Israeli politics right now: wanting Netanyahu gone doesn't mean the opposition can actually replace him.

The political landscape is deeply fragmented. While polls consistently show that Netanyahu's right-wing and religious coalition would fall short of a 61-seat majority in the 120-seat Knesset, they also show the opposition failing to secure a clean path to power.

Opposition leader Yair Lapid and his allies face a brutal mathematical reality. They cannot form a government without partnering with Arab-majority political parties. For large segments of the center-right opposition, that's a complete dealbreaker. Netanyahu is already weaponizing this gridlock. He recently shared a targeted Likud campaign ad hammering home a single, simple message: Lapid can't build a coalition without relying on Arab lawmakers.

That strategy works. The Israel Democracy Institute poll revealed that despite Netanyahu's terrible personal favorability numbers, 36% of Jewish Israelis still believe his bloc has the highest chance of forming the next government. Only 26% believe the opposition can pull it off.


A Strategy Built on Eternal War

Netanyahu's path to victory relies on shifting the conversation away from his failures and toward absolute security. He wants voters to view him as the only leader capable of managing Israel's complex security situation, which currently spans operations in Gaza, tensions in Lebanon, and confrontation with Iran.

When his opponents call the recent military ceasefires a "political disaster" that failed to yield permanent strategic results, Netanyahu's counter-argument is simple: changing leaders in the middle of an existential crisis is a luxury Israel cannot afford.

He has spent nearly two decades branding himself as "Mr. Security." He knows that as long as the public feels a deep sense of vulnerability, a significant portion of the electorate will default to the status quo rather than risk an unproven, ideologically incoherent opposition coalition.


What Happens Next

The campaign has effectively started, even if the official election date hasn't been set. Expect Netanyahu to use the coming weeks to consolidate his power further. He already faced no challengers during Likud's internal committee votes last November, meaning he has a completely unified party apparatus behind him.

If you are tracking this election, stop watching the big national popularity polls. They don't matter. Instead, focus entirely on these three shifting dynamics:

  1. Watch the polling numbers for individual centrist and center-right opposition parties like Benny Gantz's faction to see if they can siphon away moderate Likud voters.
  2. Keep an eye on whether the Arab-majority parties successfully unite their factions to drive up voter turnout, which would fundamentally alter the Knesset math.
  3. Monitor the public statements from the White House. Trump's impatience with Netanyahu is growing, and any explicit US policy shift regarding military aid or diplomatic cover will be used by the Israeli opposition as proof that Netanyahu is damaging Israel's most vital alliance.

Netanyahu is betting that he can outlast Trump's doubts, outmaneuver a fractured opposition, and convince an exhausted public that he is their only real option. It's a high-stakes gamble, but it's exactly the kind of political knife fight he has spent his entire life winning.

TC

Thomas Cook

Driven by a commitment to quality journalism, Thomas Cook delivers well-researched, balanced reporting on today's most pressing topics.